This post contains affiliate links and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links. Merci!
Philadelphia Pepper Pot – Dad was definitely not a picky eater but it took him more than thirty years to develop of taste for escargots. He preferred liver and onions.
We tried to convince him that escargots were a far better choice than tripe or even calf’s liver. To no avail.
If only we could have served up a piping hot bowl of Philadelphia pepper pot soup! Discontinued in 2010, you can still buy the canned soup if you know where to look!
While one of his frequent requests was a steaming bowl of Leek and Potato soup (a taste acquired in France during the war years), Dad also had favorite comfort food soups from childhood days in Pennsylvania Dutch country.
Admittedly, this is not an across the board favorite but more of a regional specialty – and a favorite of those who grew up in the Philadelphia area.
In other words, it’s a perfect fit for several generations of this family.
The first recipe is from the Inquirer Cook Book, an insert of the Philadelphia Inquirer dated March 31, 1949.
But… I’ve also developed my own recipe for this traditional soup. It’s a soup that keeps well and tastes even better re-heated!
The Inquirer cookbook was a four part series edited by Virginia Cheney, Home Economics editor for the Inquirer and Ruth S. Hutchinson, author of the Pennsylvania Dutch Cookbook.
We’ve tweaked this recipe a little bit depending of the availability of vegetables and meats but the unique flavors of Pepper Pot come from the fresh tripe.
I can understand where the mere idea of handling, preparing and eventually eating beef tripe might be more than some could take – even when hungry’
But admit it, if you did not know about the ingredients in any really tasty dish, you would probably eat it and ask for seconds. I know I have 🙂
Try it once following either recipe to the letter and then make it your own with a few changes to suit all taste buds then serve it pipping hot in the perfect soup bowl.
To most of my family members, tripe is that one ingredient not to be discussed. Just this week, the soup man made the following comment – “You’ve got to be kidding!” – yet he will come close to single handedly eating the entire pot of Philadelphia Pepper Pot soup without a second thought to that one ingredient.
But let’s face it, as a food, offal and particularly tripe are eaten all over the world in a variety of very tasty recipes. French recipes include some of my favorites dishes such as Tripes A La Mode de Caen (my recipe is coming up with leftover tripe from the Pepper Pot soup!) and Rognons de Veau.
A recipe for Tripes A La Mode Caen is included in a famous Cordon Bleu cookbook!
Who’s a fan of liver and onions? Anyone for tongue? How about steak and kidney pie? All recipes made with offal.
It’s not exactly what one might think of as a good reason to eat tripe in any dish but it is, in fact, good for you. It is high in cholesterol but packed with minerals, proteins and vitamins. But I digress…
Yes, tripe is chewy if not cooked correctly but its mild flavor is the perfect way to add protein to soups.
Rinse and scrub the tripe under cold running water. Place in a large dutch oven and cover with cold water.
Bring the water to a simmer on low heat and barely simmer (as in the water ripples rather than bubbles) for at least 5 hours or until the tripe is soft and easily pierced with a fork.
Anything more than a low simmer will toughen up the tripe. What you want are extremely tender bits of tripe in the soup so make sure to maintain that low simmer from the start.
Pepper Pot soup is the perfect slow cooker recipe! I would still recommend preparing the tripe as I did – separately on a slow simmer for hours on end. By the time the tripe is really tender, the remaining ingredients would be mush. Prep it ahead of time.
The rest of the soup prep can easily be made in the crock pot. Near the end of the soup and veggies cooking cycle, add the diced tripe.
When you can’t find an ingredient – improvise.
I’m not crazy about cloves in anything except baked goods but I add a couple in the soup.
The 16 inch oval prep platter I use in the kitchen is a memento of my mother-in-law’s kitchen.
As the only remaining piece of a set, I use it for all my recipe prep work. It’s a vintage Noritake The Sahara porcelain piece.
Pepper Pot soup is a Pennsylvania Dutch specialty from the Philadelphia area. The recipe below appeared in the Inquirer cookbook insert in 1949. This insert is one of two found in my mother-in-law’s recipe stash. The Inquirer cookbook was a four part series edited by Virginia Cheney, Home Economics editor for the Inquirer and Ruth S. Hutchinson, author of the Pennsylvania Dutch Cookbook. Copyright of the respective editor and author.
Philadelphia Pepper Pot soup was Dad’s favorite winter soup. As a Pennsylvania native and one-time Philadelphia resident, he often talked about a soup which to us seemed like one dish to avoid. Until we tasted it. It was easy to accommodate his and our taste buds when Campbell’s® still made the soup. Once discontinued, I set about duplicating the flavors of this regional specialty. This is the latest version.
1 1/4 lbs. fresh beef tripe ($3.99/lb) (Cooked at a low simmer for close to 6 hours). Drain, refrigerate until the next day. Fine diced before adding to soup.a href=”https://www.amazon.com/Tripe-English-Kitchen-Marjory-Houlihan/dp/1903018811/ref=as_li_ss_il?&linkCode=li3&tag=foodcrafting-20&linkId=c74c42a149ea32da594ab33698093463″ target=”_blank”>
1 1/2 lbs beef knuckle and shank meat (cooked with the vegetables, then cooled and chopped fine)
2 quarts of water or more if needed
1 large beef bouillon cube
Peppercorns, to taste (about 10)
Heaping teaspoon of red pepper flakes
Whole cloves (2 or 3)
Salt, to taste but at least 1 tablespoon
Several large sprigs of fresh thyme
Several sprigs of fresh parsley
Two very fresh bay leaves
2 cups celery, chopped
2 medium onions, rough chopped
4 carrots, chopped
2 to 3 potatoes, diced
1 cup green and red bell peppers, diced
Half (or more) of a 28 oz. can of whole peeled tomatoes
For best results, cook the tripe as directed below.
Buy very fresh tripe. Wash and scrub the tripe under cold running water. Place in a large stockpot and cover with cold water until the pieces float. You want plenty of water.
Bring to a simmer over low heat then reduce the heat until the pot barely simmers. Cover and cook for at least 5 hours, closer to six.. Mine cooked for close to 8 hours because I took a nap when I least expected to. You want the tripe to be incredibly tender.
Once cooked, drain the tripe and refrigerate until ready to use. Before adding to the soup, cut it into a fine dice.
You can prepare both the tripe and the rest of the soup in separate stock pots.
In a large stock pot, add 2 quarts of water. Place the beef shank and knuckles in the water along with all the diced vegetables and seasonings.
Bring to a simmer and simmer, covered, for a good hour or more.
Remove the meat from the pot with a skimmer and add the diced potatoes. Simmer for another hour or until the potatoes are tender. Adjust seasonings and add any liquid if needed.
While the soup continues to cook, cut up the beef (and tripe if you have not already done so) into small bits.
About 30 minutes before serving, add the beef and tripe to the soup. Continue to cook on a very low simmer but the soup is ready to serve as soon as the meat is heated through.
Philadelphia Pepper Pot soup tastes even better the next day!
Recently, while preparing several recipes that required dicing, chopping and slicing, I cut my fingers in rather unique ways.
I will not post pictures to illustrate the damage but let’s just say that the cuts were surgical.
It’s been a long time since I cut myself to such an extent. I thought I would break out the Mandoline but by then, not even the protective blade guard seemed enough to keep my fingers out of the way.
Cutting vegetables for soup is rather routine but leave it to a wet carrot to cause potentially serious damage and to an extra sharp knife not to recognize the difference between tenderloin steak and my hand! So…
I am ordering a set of gloves and keeping my fingers safe. At no point are fingers required to be part of any recipes!
1 Cook, 2 Countries & A Taste For World Cuisines: Cooking A La Mode De Chez Nous - Cuisine d'Hier Et d'Aujourd'hui! For the love of home style cooking and great food. Memories are made of this!