Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie – Time to bake a traditional Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie!
I read the Food Section of the Washington Post religiously and have for years. Some recipe clippings date back decades. Not that I do not read or listen to the “news”. Perhaps a little too much because some of the headlines have a tendency to get me all worked up and that is certainly not recommended for the old BP.
I always look forward to Wednesdays and the yummy surprises found in the Food Section of the paper.
An entire category of this personal cookbook is dedicated to traditional foods and dishes from central PA as well as multiple anecdotes related to my introduction to Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish food preparation.
Table of Contents
Learning To Like Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie
Big Valley Amish Cook-Book: a Cookbook From KishacoquillasI am not sure how long it will take me to acquire the taste – or even be willing to sample – certain dishes.
However, it does not mean I don’t prepare them for those family members who grew up with this type of cooking and those who have acquired a taste for certain recipes.
I’ll let you in on a little secret…
Yes, it includes me and Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie is one of them. Hard to escape it when both your Dad and your husband hail from the same part of the state!
And today, someone special is getting a Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie for his birthday!
Tradition lives on in this family as it has since the first Pennsylvania German ancestor arrived on these shores courtesy of William Penn. One branch of the family is , literally, chin deep in German, Dutch , Swiss and even a little French 🙂
In this Big Valley clan, Shoo-Fly Pie is not only a family favorite but a must have at the Thanksgiving table.
Would you prefer a plain serving or a fancy one? There is difference!
You might call it a coffee cake in a pie shell, but holidays would not be absolutely perfect without a Shoo-Fly Pie with a dollop of fresh whipped cream or extra creamy Cool Whip on top!
This is a crumb pie unlike any other, one with as many recipe variations as there are cooks who prepare it. You might say molasses are an acquired taste and Shoofly pie is not likely to be found too far out from Pennsylvania Dutch country.
You have a dry version and a wet version but in our home, the best Shoo-Fly is a perfectly balanced pie – with a gooey bottom layer, a moist spongy middle that gradually becomes drier as you get closer to the top…where you should have nothing more than a thin layer of golden brown crumbs.
Assembling A Perfect Shoofly Pie
It’s all in how you assemble the few ingredients in our family Shoo-Fly Pie.
I use a prepared pie crust (Thank you Pillsbury!) brought to room temperature. Short on time or not ready to try the “layering effect”? You can now buy Shoofly Pie ready made mix!
It’s a Pennsylvania classic from our bake oven to yours.
Recipe for Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie:
- ¼ cup shortening
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 1½ cup flour
- ¾ teaspoon baking soda
- ⅛ teaspoon nutmeg
- 1 little ginger, cinnamon and cloves
- ¼ teaspoon salt
- ¾ cup molasses (I use Grandma's® "unsulphured" dark molasses)
- ¾ cup boiling hot water the hotter the water, the more your filling rises to create the layered crumb
- Preheat over the 450 degrees.
- Line a 9 inch pie pan with the unbaked pie shell. Make sure the edges of the pie shell are fluted as high as possible. The liquid portion of the pie tends to bubble up and often spill.
- Prepare the crumb portion of the pie as follows:
- Cut the shortening into the brown sugar/flour mixture until crumbly. Set aside.
- Prepare the liquid portion of the pie as follows:
- Use boiling hot water. The hotter the water, the more your filling rises to create the layered crumb
- Mix all ingredients for the liquid portion together in a medium glass Pyrex bowl and add hot water. Stir gently. The mixture will fizz as the baking soda reacts.
- In unbaked pie crust, spread half of dry crumb mixture, then slowly pour all of the liquid mixture in a concentric circle so as not to disturb the bottom crumb layer. Top the liquid layer with the remaining crumbs. The liquid will not be totally covered.
- Carefully place in oven and bake at 450 degrees first 15 minutes, then lower the temperature to 350 degrees and bake for another 20 minutes or so.
- The crumbs should not burn but turn a golden brown and the liquid should be oozing out along the edges.
- Although the filling does rise, it will shrink back down some in the middle as the pie cools.
There are versions of this pie made with dark Karo® syrup and without any spices at all.
To our taste buds, it makes for a bland pie filling without the intense and traditional flavor of a true, Pennsylvania Dutch Shoo-Fly Pie.