Jello Mold Salads: Best Blast From The Past Gelatin Recipes

By La Cuisinière | Side Dishes

Oct 19

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. Merci!

Jello Mold Salads – My first introduction to molded gelatin salads came back in the early fifties.  I had no clue what Jello® was back then but I knew it was sweet so it had to be dessert.

We did not have gelatin in any “flavor” where I came from (deep in the French countryside) – just the clear gelatin used to thicken puddings and the like.

Soon , I learned about Jello®,  fruit cocktail, gelatin mold salads and tomato aspic.

 Explore the New Generation of Jello Molds

We're going vintage gelatin recipes - specifically those Jello Mold Salads that I remember seeing everywhere years ago. Never thought of them as salads!

Remember Jello Mold Salads?

BuzzFeed® lays claim to a list of “17 Horrifyingly Disgusting Retro Gelatin Recipes”.

That’s not a good sign but, apparently, Jello mold salads were quite the thing back during the 50’s and obviously much earlier than that judging from this poster.

All I recall is that my 1952 introduction to American cuisine included a Jello mold.

I vaguely remember “Aunt Grace” from Philadelphia asking why I did not like her red salad.  Although I did not speak a word of English at the time, it was difficult to reconcile calling it a salad when the red jiggly mold was full of apple chunks and sliced grapes.

Surely, she did not mean to mix the two and then add gelatin.

 1932 Ad Jell-O Gelatin Salad Lime Fluff Recipes Fruit – Original Print Ad

As it was, she was was trying to make me drink cold milk from a metal tumbler and eat square bread along with a sweet salad full of fruit!

My mind was racing.

“Can we go home now?”

Little did I suspect that barely twenty years later, I would sit down to dinner in central Pennsylvania and find a huge ring of tomato aspic sitting in front of me.

Prepared by my new mother-in-law!

So…let’s explore this very American phenomenon known as the Joys of Jello®.
Jello Mold Salads - joys-of-jello-booklet

Margaret’s Jello Mold Salads

The New Joys of Jell-OThe New Joys of Jell-O

I’ll admit it.  A chilled fruit filled dish of jello topped with Cool Whip® is a welcome dessert during the summer months.  It is light and sweet.

There was a time when the kids and I experimented with the Jello® parfaits – layers of different flavors – chilling each layer until it thickened before adding another layer – often with the fancy glasses tipped at an angle.  Remember those?

Recently, I conducted a test to see which Jello mold salads were the most memorable with the in-laws.

The results were unanimous: the tomato aspic and the “fruit cocktail” salads.

The ingredients for the tomato aspic are in the pantry – waiting for a seafood meal.  The fruit cocktail will be served as a dessert.

The Famous Tomato Aspic

2 cups of boiling tomato juice
1 (6 oz.) package of lemon gelatin
Salt, 1/2 teaspoon
1 1/2 cup of cold tomato juice
2 teaspoons of horseradish
Grated onion, 1 to 1 1/2 tablespoons
1/2 teaspoon of cayenne pepper

Dissolve the gelatin and salt in the boiling tomato juice. Add the cold tomato juice and the rest of the ingredients. Stir to combine well. Pour into 8 individual molds on in a small ring mold.

Margaret’s small ring mold is pictured below along with some of the ingredients for the famous tomato aspic recipe.

The larger 11 cup ring mold was never used!  It still sports the original Mirro® label.
Margaret’s favorite marked-up selection from The Joys of Jello® booklet is the Crab Meat Salad which uses lemon and lime gelatin.

She replaced the cottage cheese with 1 cup of whipping cream.  For this recipe, she no doubt used the curved fish Mirro® mold that is part of her collection.  How can I tell?  It looks well worn .



Jello Mold Recipes With Cool Whip®

Cool Whip® – what am I talking about! In these vintage recipes, it was referred to as Dream Whip® or a “whipped cream substitute”.

The later does not sound too appetizing but I hesitate to mention that I used Dream Whip® once upon a time.

Reading through one of my Big Valley and central Pennsylvania vintage community cookbook, I found Mrs. Lavan’s Pink Arctic Freeze salad.  See what I mean? 

Pink, salad, sugar and Dream Whip®.  On shredded lettuce.

 The Joy of Jell-O Molds: 56 Festive recipes from the classic to the contemporaryThe Joy of Jell-O Molds: 56 Festive recipes from the classic to the contemporary

Pink Arctic Freeze Salad Recipe

Cream cheese, 2  (3oz.) packages, softenend
2 tablespoons of sugar
2 tablespoons of mayonnaise
1 can of jellied cranberry sauce
1 cup of drained, crushed pineapple
1/2 cup of chopped pecans
1/2 cup of heavy cream or 1 envelope of Dream Whip® prepared according to the directions on the box.

Cream together the cream cheese and the sugar. Stir in the mayonnaise. Fold in the cranberry sauce, crushed pineapple, chopped pecans and prepared cream. Turn the mixture into a regular size loaf pan (9x5x3 inches). Freeze until firm. Cut into slices and serve on shredded lettuce. Yields 8 to 12 portions.

Cranberry Jello Mold Salad

The year was 1973.  I decided to make a cranberry jello mold for Thanksgiving.   I have no idea what possessed me.  For some reason, I thought it might replace canned cranberry sauce. Instead,  it became dessert.

My sister and her friend ate so much of it before dinner that the Thanksgiving meal almost became history.

Believe it or not but I still make it because it is that good and can easily replace chunky whole cranberry sauce for those who prefer it to the jellied variety.

Yes, the jelly version sits at the top of the list but my salad is still there as a seasonal dessert   

Mrs. Riden’s Cranberry-Raspberry Salad

1 can of whole cranberry sauce
1 (16 oz. can) crushed pineapple
2 (3 oz.) boxes of raspberry gelatin
3/4 of a cup chopped nuts
2 cups of boiling water

Dissolve the gelatin in hot water. Add remaining ingredients. Refrigerate until set.

But I could not pass this one up as a Jello mold salad grande finale – B. Nicodemus’ holiday idea 🎄for her gelatin Cranberry Salad:

“Add red food coloring to the jello mixture and serve with a mayonnaise to which green food coloring has been added.”

Enough said about Jello mold salads.  I rest my case.

Related Recipes

(Visited 1,028 times, 18 visits today)

About the Author

1 Cook, 2 Countries & A Taste For World Cuisines: Cooking A La Mode De Chez Nous - Cuisine d'Hier Et d'Aujourd'hui! For the love of home style cooking and great food. Memories are made of this!

Leave a Comment:

Leave a Comment:

error: Content is © protected !!